An Illinois couple lost their baby during childbirth in 2018 and won a $7.5 million malpractice verdict against a hospital and medical staff; on November 13, appeals judges upheld the award after a jury dispute

Spread the love


An Illinois couple lost their baby during childbirth in 2018 and won a $7.5 million malpractice verdict against a hospital and medical staff; on November 13, appeals judges upheld the award after a jury dispute
Representative image created using AI for Canva

An Illinois appeals court has affirmed a $7.5 million wrongful-death verdict in favour of Jeryis and Carlos Flores, whose daughter Cianie died during childbirth at Advocate Illinois Masonic Medical Center in 2018. The November 13 decision by the Illinois Appellate Court, First District, rejected the hospital and medical staff’s argument that the jury’s verdict was invalid because jurors did not have to agree on the same specific act of negligence, according to the Justia U.S. Law case record.The case involved claims that obstetrician Dr. Silvia Bicalho and nurse Josephine Jimenez failed to monitor the baby and intervene in time during labor. The appellate court found that the jury only needed to agree unanimously that each defendant was negligent and that the negligence caused the injury, not that all jurors agreed on which particular act or omission constituted that negligence. Read more details about this case, as per the record, here:

What happened in 2018

Jeryis Flores arrived at Advocate Illinois Masonic Medical Center at around 5 a.m. on September 26, 2018, in labor with her daughter, Cianie. Nurse Jimenez began caring for her at approximately 7 a.m., by which time Jeryis was nine centimeters dilated.Throughout the labor, medical staff used electronic fetal monitoring to track Cianie’s heart rate and Jeryis’s contractions. When the external monitor did not capture the fetal heart rate adequately, providers could use a fetal scalp electrode, which attaches to the fetus’s scalp and provides a more direct reading.At around 8:30 a.m., Dr. Bicalho examined Jeryis and determined that she was fully dilated but that Cianie remained relatively high in the birth canal. She instructed Jeryis to “labor down,” meaning to allow contractions and gravity to help the baby descend before actively pushing.

What the experts said

Plaintiffs’ obstetrical expert, Dr. Fred Duboe, testified that Dr. Bicalho deviated from the standard of care in three ways. He said she should not have instructed Jeryis to labor down after 8:30 a.m., should have placed a fetal scalp electrode by 11:15 a.m., and should have ordered an emergency cesarean section between 12:15 p.m. and 12:20 p.m.Plaintiffs’ nursing expert, Lindsay McDevitt, R.N., testified that nurse Jimenez also deviated from the standard of care. She said Jimenez failed to question the labor-down instruction, failed to advocate for earlier placement of a fetal scalp electrode, and failed to use the nursing chain of command if Dr. Bicalho did not respond to concerns.On causation, Dr. Mark Landon, a maternal-fetal medicine specialist, testified that the tracing showed repeated umbilical-cord compression and progressive loss of fetal oxygen during the second stage of labor. He said Cianie would have survived if delivered by 12:25 p.m. and that the delay in placing a fetal scalp electrode contributed to her death.

What the defence argued

The defence presented a different explanation. Their obstetrical expert testified that Dr. Bicalho appropriately instructed Jeryis to labor down, that the fetal-heart-rate tracing did not warrant earlier placement of a scalp electrode, and that the standard of care did not require an emergency cesarean section before 12:51 p.m.Their pathologist, Dr. Ricardo Lastra, attributed the death to fetal vascular malperfusion, a condition involving reduced blood flow from the fetus to the placenta. He said the condition could not have been diagnosed before delivery.Their neonatology expert, Dr. Jeffrey Loughead, opined that a complete and unpreventable blockage of the umbilical cord occurred shortly before delivery. On cross-examination, however, he agreed that Cianie likely would have survived if delivered approximately 13 to 15 minutes earlier.

The jury’s question

During deliberations, the jury asked whether it needed to be unanimous on one count or could be unanimous on any combination of the alleged acts or omissions. The trial court responded that jurors had to unanimously agree that each defendant was negligent but did not need to agree on which of the three possible acts constituted that negligence.Defendants argued that this response violated their constitutional right to a unanimous verdict. They said jurors could have imposed liability without agreeing that any particular act or omission was negligent or caused the injury.The trial court had relied on Galich v. Advocate Health & Hospital Corp., a 2024 Illinois appellate decision involving a similar jury question. The court told the jury it must make a unanimous decision that each defendant was negligent, but did not need to agree on which of the three possible acts constituted that negligence.

What the appeals court decided

The Illinois Appellate Court affirmed the trial court’s response. It held that a unanimous verdict required each juror to find that the defendant was negligent and that the negligence proximately caused the injury, but did not require agreement on which specific act or omission established those findings.The court explained that Illinois law treats multiple alleged departures from the standard of care as alternative bases for a single claim of liability. A general verdict can stand if at least one theory is supported by the evidence and unaffected by prejudicial error.The court also rejected the defendants’ proposed special interrogatories, which would have asked jurors whether they unanimously agreed on a particular negligent act and its causal relationship to the injury. The trial court had refused those interrogatories because it believed they would contradict the response it had already given and could lead jurors to believe they needed to agree on a specific act.

Why the ruling matters

The decision clarifies how Illinois courts handle jury unanimity in medical negligence cases involving multiple alleged acts or omissions. It confirms that jurors do not need to agree on the same specific departure from the standard of care, as long as they unanimously agree that the defendant was negligent and that the negligence caused the injury.That principle matters because medical negligence cases often involve several overlapping allegations. In this case, plaintiffs pointed to the labor-down instruction, the timing of the fetal scalp electrode, and the timing of the emergency cesarean section, among other issues.The ruling also shows how appellate courts can affirm a jury verdict even when they don’t know everything that went into it. As long as the legal standard for unanimity is met, the general verdict can stand.

What it means to the Flores family

The appellate ruling brings the Flores family a major step closer to closure. The jury’s $7.5 million award, plus costs and prejudgment interest, remains in place, bringing the total judgment to more than $9.1 million.This case highlights that although delivery is often routine, it can become dangerous if there is delay in monitoring and intervention. It also highlights the importance of expert testimony in helping juries understand complex medical decisions and their consequences.For now, the appellate court’s ruling stands. The Flores family’s claim has been upheld, and the legal question about jury unanimity has been answered in a way that supports the verdict they received.



Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *