Five years after emerging as a startup founded by former OpenAI employees, Anthropic has made history with the biggest public stock offering ever. But while its blockbuster Nasdaq debut has demonstrated strong investor appetite for artificial intelligence, the company’s first day on Wall Street has also highlighted the growing contradictions surrounding the AI boom.Anthropic shares opened at $111.50, around 34% above their initial public offering (IPO) price of $83, before closing at $97.17, up 17.07%.The company raised $81.31 billion through the offering, surpassing SpaceX’s $75 billion fundraising haul. Its valuation briefly crossed $2 trillion during the first few minutes of trading before settling at around $1.75 trillion at the close.The strong debut, however, did little to lift sentiment across the broader technology sector. US stocks came under pressure on Thursday, while Anthropic shares fell in premarket trading on Friday, reflecting concerns that the initial excitement around the listing may not translate into sustained investor confidence in AI companies.The company’s listing is particularly significant because it is among the first major AI developers to enter the public markets. Its performance will be closely watched as a measure of whether investors are willing to continue backing companies that are spending enormous sums to build AI infrastructure, even as questions persist over their profitability.“Anthropic’s IPO attracted strong investor demand, with the stock opening 34% above its IPO price and closing 17% higher. However, the broader AI and technology stocks came under pressure, highlighting that a successful listing does not automatically lift the wider sector. The broader market was already under strain, and investors are reassessing valuations and the amount of capital flowing into AI,” Prateek Gupta, Head of Business at Mudrex, told TOI.“The listing also opens a new route for retail investors to access a company previously available largely through private markets. However, sustained performance will depend on business fundamentals and the ability to meet growth expectations. Investors should look beyond the initial rally and focus on valuation and long-term potential,” Gupta added.Shares retreat after blockbuster debutAnthropic shares fell around 6% in premarket trading on Friday, slipping to $91.24 after closing at $97.17 on Thursday.The decline brought the company’s fully diluted valuation to approximately $1.7 trillion, while its market capitalisation based on shares outstanding stood at around $1.2 trillion, Reuters reported.Investors will now be watching whether the stock can sustain its early gains or experience further volatility as the excitement surrounding the listing fades.Anthropic’s stock is also being viewed as a gauge of investor appetite for the wider AI industry. A sustained decline could deepen concerns about high valuations and the huge amounts being invested in AI development and infrastructure.The shares closed nearly 13% below their opening price on Thursday, indicating that trading could remain volatile in the initial weeks as some investors look to book quick profits.“A decline in share value is normal following a high-profile listing, but we don’t know if that decline will be in line with other IPOs or more volatile, and that should raise alarms for investors,” Tejal Patel, executive director at the SOC Investment Group, told Reuters.The listing has also drawn comparisons with SpaceX, whose shares experienced sharp price swings in the weeks following its own public debut in June. Some investors have cautioned against rushing to buy Anthropic shares immediately after the listing.Retail investor participation was particularly strong with trading in Anthropic shares worth around $772 million on Thursday, the highest for an IPO debut since Vanda Research began tracking the data in 2012.The focus is now shifting to rival OpenAI, which has indicated that it could go public next year. Its potential listing would provide another major test of investor appetite for AI stocks.Competition is also intensifying. Apple is developing an AI agent capable of performing tasks on behalf of users, entering a market already being pursued by Anthropic, OpenAI and Meta Platforms, Bloomberg News reported.From AI safety startup to Wall Street giantAnthropic was founded in 2021 by seven former OpenAI employees, including chief executive Dario Amodei and his sister Daniela Amodei, who is the company’s president.The founders left OpenAI over differences in their approach to developing artificial intelligence, seeking to build a company that placed greater emphasis on safety.The company subsequently developed Claude, an AI chatbot that competes with OpenAI’s ChatGPT and Google’s AI offerings.Safety has remained central to Anthropic’s identity. However, the company’s rapid growth has brought it into the middle of a debate over whether the industry is moving too quickly to develop increasingly powerful AI systems without fully understanding their consequences.Speaking at the Nasdaq opening bell, Dario Amodei described the tension between safety and technological advancement as one of the “central tensions at the heart of the company”.In an interview with CNBC, he compared the rapid pace of AI development, partly driven by advanced models helping build improved versions of themselves, to allowing a driver to travel at 200 miles per hour after previously driving at 60 miles per hour.“What we’ve done with pacing is essentially said, ‘Look, you know, we could drive at 200 miles an hour. Maybe let’s only drive at 90 miles an hour, spend time figuring out how to do that safely,'” he said. “And the rest of that surplus, we spend building the model in the right way.”However, concerns about the company’s safety practices have also emerged from within the AI industry. In September, Anthropic researcher Jacob Coxon resigned criticising the safety practices of both Anthropic and OpenAI.In his message, he warned that the companies were “gambling with our lives”, triggering wider discussions about the risks associated with the rapid development of AI.Amodei subsequently published an essay calling for a slowdown in AI development and greater coordination among companies and governments. He also advocated independent evaluations of AI systems to ensure that safety measures keep pace with technological advances.A recent report by the nonprofit Model Evaluation and Threat Research, however, found that Anthropic was developing its systems around twice as quickly as it had a year earlier, largely because AI itself was helping accelerate the development process.At the Nasdaq opening bell, Amodei acknowledged that the company’s biggest safety challenges were still ahead. “And to state it unequivocally, we will pace the training and deployment of AI systems, taking as long as is necessary to have confidence that they are safe and will remain under human control,” he said.Anthropic itself flags catastrophic AI risksDespite positioning itself as a company focused on developing safer AI, Anthropic has acknowledged that the technology could pose serious risks to humanity.In a filing with the US Securities and Exchange Commission last month, the company devoted 93 pages to outlining potential risks associated with its business. These included the possibility that advanced AI systems could pose “catastrophic or existential risks to humanity.”While Anthropic has argued that openly discussing these risks is part of its commitment to transparency, critics have questioned the contrast between its warnings about the dangers of AI and its position as a company developing increasingly powerful AI systems.The contradiction is particularly relevant as the company enters the public markets. It will now have to balance its commitment to safety and its broader public mission with the expectations of shareholders seeking sustained growth and profits.For investors, the question is no longer simply whether AI will transform industries. It is whether the companies driving that transformation can generate enough revenue to justify their valuations and enormous investments.Anthropic’s record listing has demonstrated that investor appetite for AI remains strong. But its volatile debut also suggests that enthusiasm alone may not be enough to keep the sector’s valuations rising.
